In 1786, a Monthly Meeting was established as part of the Warrington and Fairfax Quarterly Meeting, which included York and the Newberry Preparative Meeting.
By the mid 1850's the meetinghouse was in need of extensive repairs, which were accomplished, but in 1858, the meeting was discontinued and its remaining members transferred to the care of Baltimore Monthly Meeting as an indulged worship group. In 1933, the meeting was re-established as a Preparative meeting, and, finally, in 1951, the York Monthly Meeting was established once again under Warrington Quarterly Meeting.